Vinegar Cake – an Egg-Free Fruit Cake
Vinegar in a cake? Well yes, it helps to make this egg-free fruit cake rise in a rather spectacular fashion. The vinegar cake has a nice soft crumb and is pleasantly fruity as well as malty with an unexpected sort of sprightliness about it.
Ros chose V for Alpha Bakes this month, oh my goodness! Other than Vanilla and Victoria sandwich, I wasn’t having many ideas and although vanilla is fantastic, it’s such a common ingredient in cakes, I wanted something a little different. I’ve seen Viennese whirls popping up all over the place which is a great idea, but again not quite what I was looking for.
So I turned to trusty Pam Corbin in her wonderful book Cakes and there it was at the bottom of the V list, Vinegar Cake. Traditionally, it was made by farmer’s wives when their hens were off lay. So it’s an eggless fruit cake and it comes from East Anglia. I changed things of course and added a few ingredients not mentioned in Pam’s recipe.
Vinegar Cake
There’s quite a lot of fun to be had with this fruit cake. I watched in awe as the milk and vinegar mixture whooshed up when I added the bicarbonate of soda. It reminded me of one of those school science lessons which probably no longer occur due to health and safety reasons. Whatever the underlying chemistry of it all, it worked and the cake rose really well.
I used 1 tbsp mesquite powder and 1 tbsp maca powder, placed them on the scales then added plain flour to make the weight up to 250g. But I’ve omitted these from the recipe below.
As dried fruit is really plenty sweet enough already, I’ve only added a couple of spoonfuls of golden syrup to the mix. There is a little demerara sugar scattered over the top too. I used a mix of sultanas, raisins, chopped dried apples, goji berries and homemade crystallised orange peel.
Surprisingly, the taste of vinegar is only noticeable by its absence. It has a fabulous crunchy top and is lovely if you serve it warm with clotted cream or ice-cream. I’m not a fan of heavy fruit cakes, but this was just about right, plenty of fruit but plenty of cake too.
CT is also not a fan of heavy fruitcakes, which he associates with being dense, dry and desiccated with bucket loads of horrible mixed peel. This one, he opined, was pleasantly fruity with an unexpected sort of spritliness about it. It has a nice soft crumb and tastes slightly malty which I put down to the mesquite I added. We both felt thoroughly virtuous eating this because of the healthful properties of the maca I also included.
Keep in Touch
Thanks for visiting Tin and Thyme. If you make this vinegar cake, I’d love to hear about it in the comments below. Do share photos on social media too and use the hashtag #tinandthyme, so I can spot them.
For more delicious and nutritious recipes, follow me on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram or Pinterest.
Vinegar Cake – The Recipe
Vinegar Cake
Ingredients
- 250 g plain flour (I used 1 tbsp mesquite powder and 1 tbsp maca powder, placed them on the scales then added plain flour to make the weight up to 250g)
- 250 g wholemeal flour
- pinch of salt
- 200 g unsalted butter - cut into small pieces
- 500 g dried fruit (I used a mix of sultanas, raisins, chopped dried apples, goji berries and homemade crystallised orange peel)
- 50 g dark chocolate - chopped (I used Maya Gold, Green & Blacks orange spiced)
- 300 ml milk + 1 tbsp for mixing
- 50 ml cider vinegar
- 1 tsp bicarbonate of soda
- 2 tbsp golden syrup
- 1 tbsp demerara sugar
Instructions
- Sift the flours (along with mesquite and / or maca if using) into a bowl along with the salt.
- Rub in the butter until the mixture resembles breadcrumbs.
- Stir in the dried fruit and chocolate.
- Pour the milk into a large jug or bowl and add the vinegar.
- In a cup, stir the bicarbonate of soda into 1 tbsp of milk until dissolved.
- Add this to the milk mixture and watch in amazement as it froths up and up and up.
- Pour onto the dry ingredients together with 2 tbsp golden syrup and mix until just incorporated.
- Spoon into a 23cm round silicone cake mould or lined tin and smooth the top.
- Sprinkle the demerara sugar over the top and bake at 170℃ (338℉, Gas 3) for 50 minutes, or until the cake is risen and an inserted toothpick comes out more or less clean.
- Leave to cool for 20 minutes then turn out onto a wire rack to cool completely - if you can wait that long.
Notes
Nutrition
Sharing
Alpha Bakes is a monthly blogging challenge where a random letter is picked from the alphabet which then inspires the theme of the bake. It’s hosted alternately by Ros of The More Than Occasional Baker and Caroline Makes.
DollyBakes
24th June 2012 at 7:27 amOoh I love the idea of this cake!!! x
Choclette
24th June 2012 at 9:26 amThank you, It is a very tasty cake, though I say it myself 😉
Suelle
24th June 2012 at 8:29 amThis sounds delicious! I’m beginning to realise there’s a whole world of new cakes which will open up when my CT leaves home!
Are you sure it’s not the maca powder which made the cake ‘sprightly’? I’ve just looked up what it is and one reference was for increased libido! LOL!
Choclette
24th June 2012 at 9:25 amOh Suelle, I nearly fell off my chair laughing, thank you so much for brightening up my morning 🙂
Is your CT going to be leaving home soon?
Janice
24th June 2012 at 8:34 amNo idea what mesquite or maca powder are, will have to look them up.
Choclette
24th June 2012 at 9:27 amWell I like to keep you all guessing sometimes Janice 😉
fiona maclean
24th June 2012 at 8:39 amas janice said! BUT, just wanted to add, trust you to find a fruit cake with CHOCOLATE!!!
Choclette
24th June 2012 at 9:28 amNo, no Fiona, I didn’t find a fruit cake with chocolate, that bit was all my idea 😀
Juliet
24th June 2012 at 9:25 amSay Whaaat? Vinegar cake sounds awesome – and could be a great standby for when my vegetarian-vegan-swinging sister-in-las stops by. I never know which side of the meat free knife she’s on, so this is good for being better safe than sorry!
Choclette
25th June 2012 at 10:24 amThanks Juliet. Beware of vegan, it may have no eggs, but it does have butter, so you’d need to substitute with oil – don’t see why that wouldn’t work though.
manu
24th June 2012 at 9:43 amOMG never heard vinegar cake…I should give it a try!! Happy Sunday
Choclette
25th June 2012 at 10:25 amManu, give it a try – it’s worth it just for the whoosh!
Dom at Belleau Kitchen
24th June 2012 at 11:09 ammmm… I love a cake that is more pudding than cake… i’ve just made one in fact but never made anything like this with vinegar… sounds very ‘make-do-and-mend’ like the kind of thing done in the war… looks delicious!
Choclette
25th June 2012 at 10:26 amYes Dom, it does sound like a war cake, although I wonder what they’d have done about the goji berries 😉
Katie
24th June 2012 at 12:24 pmNever seen a cake quite like this before and filled with such an array of tasty and interesting ingredients. What is mesquite? I thought it was a smokey wood used in BBQ sauce, but am sure you didn’t add wood chippings to the cake 🙂
Choclette
25th June 2012 at 11:49 amHi Katie, mesquite is a Mexican bush growing in the dessert that produces a bean. This can be used in baking as a part substitute for flour and provides a nutty, sweet almost butterscotch flavour. Strangely wood chips don’t really do it for me 😉
Phil in the Kitchen
24th June 2012 at 3:05 pmI’ve seen recipes for vinegar cakes in a number of old recipe books and I’ve often wondered what they’d be like but never got around to making one. It looks really good – and there’s something very pleasing about a traditional fruit cake.
Choclette
25th June 2012 at 11:52 amPhil, I’d love to have a browse around your recipe books, sounds as though you have some real gems there. I’d say it would be hard to tell there were no eggs in the cake – all very interesting.
The Caked Crusader
24th June 2012 at 4:07 pmI’ve wanted to make a vinegar cake but the name has always put me off. Seeing how lovely yours looks I will have to reconsider!
Choclette
25th June 2012 at 11:59 amOh don’t let the name deter you CC, it’s a fascinating process and I really couldn’t taste the vinegar in this one.
Laura loves cakes
24th June 2012 at 4:58 pmVinegar is definitely the most original ‘V’ I’ve seen! I went for the Viennese Whirls but then made a second bake with vodka! This looks great and I want to make it, mainly so I can get the bicarb to fizz up…simple things and all that!! 🙂
Choclette
25th June 2012 at 12:08 pmLaura the fizz is really good fun and I reckon vodka is pretty original too 🙂
Green Dragonette
24th June 2012 at 7:24 pmWhat an intriguing recipe! Mesquite powder-where did you find this??
Choclette
25th June 2012 at 12:11 pmAhh, I stock up with all things weird and wonderful whenever I visit Totnes – Greenlife, it’s a great store if ever you’re passing that way. I think they have an online service too.
Baking Addict
24th June 2012 at 10:57 pmI had to look up mesquite powder and maca powder too! Thanks for entering this to AlphaBakes – a brilliant use of ‘V’!! I’m pleased to hear that you can’t taste the vinegar. Please send me a slice 🙂
Choclette
25th June 2012 at 3:43 pmHehe Ros, I wouldn’t have been best pleased if it had tasted strongly of vinegar – I am not a fan. Slice on it’s way 😉
CorrieCooks
25th June 2012 at 5:57 amThis is definitely one for me to try…the chemical reaction of the fizzing replaces the need for the raising agent in eggs, of which I have a couple of recipes. Thanks for another! 🙂
Choclette
25th June 2012 at 3:46 pmYou’re welcome Corrie, presumably, this would work with most cakes. It was certainly fun watching the fizzing process.
Debby
25th June 2012 at 6:45 amVinegar cake…oh that sounds unusual…I’ve never heard of that one before…
It’s really good to hear about an eggless cake as I’m on the look out for vegan recipes at the moment and possibly I could substitute butter with coconut butter or olive oil…Haven’t heard of Mesquite or maca powder I must do some research…
Thanks for sharing this interesting recipe…
Deb
Choclette
25th June 2012 at 3:49 pmHi Deb. I’ve made a vegan chocolate cake before using balsamic vinegar, which was good. I’ve got a few vegan recipes on my site if you look at the vegan label down the side or do a search in the search box. Nonnettes are another eggless cake, which are one of my favourites at the moment, though have no idea how it would work with oil. this fruit cake would be fine with oil I’d have thought.
thelittleloaf
25th June 2012 at 8:13 amWhen I read the title I was slightly dubious about this cake, but it’s only a small amount of vinegar and I think slightly undersells what looks like an absolutely gorgeous fruit cake. Definitely more exciting than vanilla!
Choclette
26th June 2012 at 5:43 pmHehe, it’s a great title – nothing more likely to put you off, well perhaps a few things, but you know what I mean 😉 But I liked the title, it makes you do a double take.
laura@howtocookgoodfood
25th June 2012 at 4:22 pmA very clever choice for your “v” entry and one I would jump at the chance to try. I adore vinegar and all sour sharp tastes. I know it would not be an obvious kick in this recipe but I am sure it adds another dimension and one which is novel to me!
Choclette
26th June 2012 at 5:46 pmThanks Laura. I’ve made a vegan chocolate cake using balsamic vinegar which turned out well, but it didn’t use the same method as this. Yes, I’m happy to go with the extra dimension – vinegar is a great ingredient to lots of things.
Gloria
25th June 2012 at 5:40 pmlook really yummy!
Choclette
26th June 2012 at 5:47 pmThanks Gloria – it’s actually a surprisingly good fruit cake.
Caroline
25th June 2012 at 7:30 pmThat looks great – I too had that one bookmarked for this challenge but ran out of time, and also had an excess of eggs – not a great cake to be baking when too many eggs are the problem!!! Good to know it’s a nice light fruitcake – I’ll try and remember to bake it next time I need cake and eggs are not forthcoming. It’s always fun to see chemistry in action in baking isn’t it – I keep meaning to make honeycomb for this reason alone!
Choclette
26th June 2012 at 5:49 pmOh C, you mean it wasn’t just me 😉 I had far more success with this fizzing up than I ever do with honeycomb, it was fun to watch.
cakeboule
25th June 2012 at 8:50 pmI agree with the res never heard of vinegar cake but glad to see it has not eggs in it as I have been looking for eggless cakes and not found any yet – perfect timing!
Choclette
26th June 2012 at 5:52 pmAhh cakeboule, this is a good tasty fruit cake, but do check out the nonnettes I’ve made. They are also eggless and are my favourite cake at the moment – I’ve done two different ones and both were delicious. I’ve also done a few vegan cakes which turned out well. If you’re interested, you’ll find them under the vegan tab down the side.
Johanna GGG
26th June 2012 at 2:18 pmI’ve never heard a cake called vinegar cake but I have quite a few cake recipes with vinegar in them – as I understand it the vinegar balances the baking powder or helps it rise or something so it all makes sense when you understand the chemistry (which obviously I would fail if this were a school test) – and what fruit cake cannot be improved by chocolate – sounds lovely
Choclette
26th June 2012 at 5:57 pmHi Johanna, yes it has a similar effect to yogurt being used with bicarb – it’s the alkali reacting with the acid.
Working London Mummy Working London Mummy
27th June 2012 at 9:44 pmV is for very clever and interesting! well done on this. Cookign really is like chemistry!
Choclette
9th February 2013 at 9:18 pmThank you, I like the sound of that V 😉
Wendy@The Omnivorous Bear
29th June 2012 at 9:35 amWow! I am going to give this a try… though I may have trouble sourcing mesquite. This looks fascinating – I can’t wait to have a traditional English afternoon tea party. This would be a great addition.
Choclette
9th February 2013 at 9:19 pmDid you ever try it Wendy? The mesquite is my own addition and can quite happily be substituted with flour.
Lucy Taylor
7th February 2013 at 6:11 amMMM love fruitcakes! Will try this one when my friend comes to stay as she has an egg allergy.
Choclette
9th February 2013 at 9:17 pmThanks Lucy, it’s always handy to have something up one’s sleeve for such occasions.