Vegetarian food blog featuring delicious and nutritious whole food recipes, creative baking and luscious chocolate.

Byron Bay Butterbursts

Food Reviews | 3rd March 2011 | By

When I heard that Byron Bay bakehouse had come up with a new line of biscuits, I was keen to try them after my last experience and gladly accepted an offer from Beyond the Bean to do so. Like the Byron Bay cookies before them, these butterbursts are meant for the cafe trade and come wrapped in pairs.

One of the first things I normally do when looking at a mass produced product is read the list of ingredients. I was a little disappointed to read rather a long list. It started off well enough with wheat flour, sugar and salted butter. It then went rather down hill with vegetable fat (vegetable oils, water, salt, E475, flavouring, colours: annatto, curcumin) I had to look this one up – polyglycerol esters of fatty acids – if that means anything to anyone???

Choc Hazelnut

At this point, I started to get a bit unhappy – why did these upmarket and what I had previously considered to be good quality products need the ubiquitous and highly dubious vegetable oil in them? When I read vegetable oil, I immediately think of unsustainable palm oil plantations, felled rainforests and rare orangutans. Given that they state their ingredients are ethically sourced, I would be interested to hear why the Byron Bay Cookie Company feel it’s necessary to use this.

The vegetable oil aside, these make good eating for mass produced biscuits and taste almost as good as home made ones. These were smaller and thinner than the original Byron Bay Cookies and also crisper and firmer. Two out of three biscuits were very tasty and none of them were too sweet. They did, however, leave a bit of a greasy feel in the mouth – back to that vegetable fat again! I’ve subsequently noticed that a pack of two are on sale in the cafe at work for 60p and I’ve heard some quite positive comments.

Citrus Lemon

Choc Hazelnut – these had a good chocolatey flavour and generous quantities of hazelnuts were included which gave additional interest to the texture. A tasty biscuit.

Citrus Lemon – these had a buttery texture reminiscent of shortbread with a not overly powerful lemon taste of lemon. Real lemon juice is used although there is lemon flavouring as well. These were our favourite of the three; CT reckoned he could demolish a fair few of them.

Passionfruit – these were the ones I was most excited about eating – I adore passionfruit. Unfortunately, these were the ones I was most disappointed with. The first thing I noticed on opening the packet was a strong smell of passionfruit – too strong perhaps. Despite the addition of real fruit puree to the general ingredients used, I’m sorry to say they tasted artificial. I put this down to the passionfruit flavouring listed.



    3rd March 2011 at 8:53 am

    That is disappointing, when you get excited by something only to see that they have a long paragraph of ingredients. I haven’t tried any of these ones.

    (It’s funny you’re eating Australian ones and I was eating English ones. Two by Two- Natural Toffee Biscuits, and surprisingly nothing scary in the ingredients. They were so good! A real treat for packet biscuits.)

  2. Kath

    3rd March 2011 at 10:06 am

    A good review Choc. I was talking about this very subject last night with my folks. Homemade biscuits go soft after a few days and so bought ones need all sorts of things in them to keep them firm. What these added ingredients are doing to us in the long term goodness only knows. All the more reason for us all to carry on baking.

  3. Suman Singh

    3rd March 2011 at 1:54 pm

    would love to try this sometime..thanks for the review!

  4. Chele

    3rd March 2011 at 2:56 pm

    Now the passionfruit cookies in your photo had me hooked but I agree with you, there is no need to upmarket produce to conatin unhealthy and unethical products. Not so sure I will be trying these
    now ;0(

  5. blackbookkitchendiaries

    4th March 2011 at 7:23 pm

    what a great review. thank you for sharing this. they look lovely.

  6. Choclette

    5th March 2011 at 8:35 am

    CityHippy – The world of commerce is a strange one. I haven’t heard of those.

    Kath – good point, I hadn’t thought about what keeps commercial biscuits crisp.

    Suman – thanks for your comment

    Chele – the passionfruit sounded good, but didn’t really taste so. The lemon and chocolate ones were very tasty though.

    BlackBook – thank you.

  7. mostly about chocolate blog

    5th March 2011 at 11:22 pm

    I don’t understand why companies feel it necessary to “enhance” the flavour of a natural fruit by adding a nasty tasting synthetic that is also volitile.

    Maybe the mass market enjoys the flavour though and I guess if everyone else pays for it, some of us have to keep searching.

  8. Choclette

    6th March 2011 at 3:07 pm

    Mostly about choc – I don’t understand it either, it’s sucha a shame. It would be interesting to know how popular the passionfruit biscuits prove to be.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *